Nana Hannah's Piano: baseball and piano aren't the only lessons in this book

I won Nana Hannah's Piano in a raffle basket and loved the title.  Then in looking at the book and reading the "Dear Parents" note I really wasn't sure my girls and I would like the story line.  I'm happy to say that the book was a success in my home.

The Details:


Written by Barbara Bottner
Illustrations by Diana Cain Bluthenthal
Copyright 1996

This story is about a boy who loves baseball.  He has to take piano lessons, but all he really wants to do is play ball!  When his grandma gets injured he spends a week with her.  She loves tango, and has a piano she enjoys playing.  While he's with his grandma he gets her interested in baseball (it's not as good as tango) and she plays a little on the piano.  He wants to do something that will cheer grandma up and slowly comes up with playing her a song on the piano.  Only after he finally finds a song that he loved does he realize that he can like and do more than one thing.

The story is cute and if you have a boy in your house who loves baseball but you want him to do something else as well, then this book fits that small niche.   Don't give up on this cute story if your child doesn't fall into that niche.  I have two girls, neither of which play a sport, an instrument, or take dance lessons so my children' don't have anything relateable to the book at all, or so I thought.

Turns out after reading it they really enjoyed the story, and have asked for it to be read to them a few times now.  So why is this book one they like?

Each page has only one to two good sentences on it.  This makes them fast paced, easy to follow and great for those who are having a hard time with reading or a read together book for those learning how to read.

The illustrations are full or color and life!  The facial details are what I'm drawn to, the scowl on the piano instructor's face, the tongue sticking out in constration on the boy, the smirk of amusment on the grandmas face.  These details are what make it great for me because you can ask what they are feeling or what are they thinking about.

Beyond just the sentence structure and illustrations there are a couple universal lessons that each person can connect with:

1.  to learn someone, and enjoy it one must have a good teacher.
2.  children want to help others.
3. .we are not limited to only doing one thing.
4.  don't give up on yourself

These lessons, that we can all connect with, I think are the reason why children who don't fit into the small niche that I think this book was written for, love this book.  Think about them each this way:

1.   A teacher who knows everything, yet has no compassion for the person they are teaching will not break through.  A teacher needs compassion, understanding, and fluid ways to connect with who they are teaching.  The piano teacher may have been very predominant in her field but the child was only scowled at, intimidated, and heard that he was hopeless.  Oh how terrible.  One teacher like that will ruin a subject for a child.  Kids absorb what they hear and see all the time and believe that.  I wouldn't want to play piano with that teacher either!

2.  The boy went over to the grandmothers and wanted to help her.  He showed her what he loved, but when that still didn't cheer her up he tried playing the piano knowing she enjoys that.  Kids while they do things they know we won't like, they are only doing that for attention.  Notice a child the next time someone in the house is injured or sick.  They will try their hardest to make that person happy and to be helpful.  Last week I lost my voice, it was awful, but my oldest did everything she could to be a help.  She read to her sister (now this is my daughter who struggles with reading and really doesn't like to) she read to me, she made me a card, and she could be heard saying "you know mommy can't talk so we have to be really good" to her little sister.

3.  There is nothing that says we need to limit the things we want to accomplish.  I remember reading a great children's book that went into this,  When I Grow Up that I will have to write up a review on.  We are not limited in our skill, unless we set (or don't believe in) them ourselves.  Why can't a boy be great at the piano and baseball?  Why can't a girl be a wonderful dancer and musician?  Why can't you be a coder, runner, and singer?  Always be open to trying new things!

4.  I really didn't like when the mother said "We don't have quitter in this family" because I don't think children should be forced to do something they don't want.  Why keep spending money on dance lessons when your child cries and fights you about putting on the tap shoes?  At the same time tho, if it's only because it's hard and not because it's not something they don't like then yeah you have to stick with it.  The message of practice, and perseverance is clear in the story.  The boy practices and keeps playing one song until he gets it.  Hard work pays off.

Now that I've shared about the subtle lessons in the book let's go over some activities you can do with this book either in your home, classroom, or story time.  The way the book is structured it does make it easy to read aloud to a group of children.

You can have a whole lesson on baseball from the book, what each position is, terms, and how to play.  You can use the vocab from the book to make a display, or set up and play a game of ball.

Have them write about what their grandmas like to do and are good at.  It would make a great grandparent's day book.  What activity would they give up to do something with their grandma? Use open ended questions about grandma for journal prompts for older children.

Then there's the obvious music lessons you can connect with the book. Play the song "Take Me Out to the Ball Game" what are the lyrics, learn to sing it.  What does sheet music look like?  How do you read that?  How do you play the piano?  Use apps or books or get a lesson or take a class on the piano.  What songs are played for tango?  What is tango?  Learn to dance the tango!


I hope this book has inspired you to look beyond the first impression of a book and to find deeper meanings and lessons you can take from books you read.  May your children have many passions and skills that they explore.

I hope you enjoy the activities I listed above, I'm sure there are more you can do with this lovely book, comment below something you love about the book or an activity you did.